What a ridiculously bold, unfounded, and unnecessary assessment. There's not a single opinion stated in there that's based on fact.
"kelly.j.anderson" wrote:
It is an inevitability that Apple will release an app store for the Apple TV in the not too distant future and that app store will blow the Roku channel store out of the watter in every way (Unless Roku has an astounding OS update up their sleeve)
While I would agree that it's inevitable that Apple will release an app store for the Apple TV, it's taken them over 6 months to update the firmware for the iPad, what makes you think they'll update the Apple TV in the "not too distant future"? And even if they did, there will still be a fair wait for new apps to be developed and approved for the device.
"kelly.j.anderson" wrote:
9 months from today the Apple TV 3 will come out at $99.00 and the Apple TV 2 will drop to $59.00
The first generation Apple TV is still more expensive than the new Apple TV, and there were 4 years between the two. What makes you think they'll release a new version in under a year? And if it's as good as you seem to think it will be, why would they need to?
"kelly.j.anderson" wrote:
(when a $99 GTV box comes out)
Do you have some information that no one else does? The current Google TV is $299. What makes you think there will be a $200 price drop anytime soon?
"kelly.j.anderson" wrote:
1) A retail strategy, with out being in retail they simply will not have the mind share required to be compared to the other products.
Roku already has a retail strategy, via their partnership with Netgear. The Netgear Roku boxes are already available at Fry's, and will soon be available at Best Buy and other big box stores.
"kelly.j.anderson" wrote:
2) An enhanced OpenGL based interface that allows for fast and high end graphical interfaces to compete with the rich interfaces on their competition.
Roku has already hinted at major interface updates coming. That aside, I personally find the current Apple TV Netflix interface to be very cumbersome and unfriendly. Otherwise the interface elsewhere is nothing but a black screen with cover art and reflections, with a soft blue glow around black buttons. I'm not really sure what's "high end" or "rich" about that, but ok...
"kelly.j.anderson" wrote:
3) An enhanced SDK that allows developers to work as fast and efficiently as the Google TV SDK and the Apple iOS SDK
Have you developed using the Android and iOS SDKs? While certainly more robust, I wouldn't categorize either one as fast or efficient. I can produce an app using the Roku SDK in less than a day, whereas producing the same app for Android or iOS would take a week or more. Unless you've developed on each of these platforms, I'm not sure how you can make any judgment here.
All of that aside, the OP asked about current Roku market share, not where you personally think Roku will be in a year. With nearly a million devices sold, I think they have a pretty significant lead on any competitive devices, especially when those devices haven't even been available for a month yet...
EDIT: I just read the blog linked in your profile, and it seems to have the opposite opinion of what you posted here. What's up with that?
My Channels: http://roku.permanence.com - Twitter: @TheEndlessDev
Instant Watch Browser (NetflixIWB), Aquarium Screensaver (AQUARIUM), Clever Clocks Screensaver (CLEVERCLOCKS), iTunes Podcasts (ITPC), My Channels (MYCHANNELS)