Forum Discussion

mlissbuck's avatar
mlissbuck
Reel Rookie
11 months ago

Does Blu-ray (HDMI) give Roku better audio & visual?

I’m having my 55in Roku mounted above a fireplace with no visible cables. Right now it’s on a tv console and connected to a Blu-ray DVD player via HDMI. I’ve read in several instructions that this HDMI connection between DVD player and TV gives Roku better audio and visual quality. Is this true? Will I get the same audio and visual quality on my Roku if I don’t connect the HDMI via DVD player once Roku is mounted? If the answer is NO, I may need to rethink where I place my Roku. Thanks for clarifying. 

6 Replies

  • atc98092's avatar
    atc98092
    Community Streaming Expert

    HDMI (which has nothing to do with Blu-ray other than a BD player requires using HDMI) will not improve the audio or video of a DVD. All HDMI does is provide a single cable connection between the player and the display, instead of the three separate audio/video cables previously used. It does keep the video and audio signal in the digital realm, but that in itself can't "improve" the signal. It can potentially keep stray electronic "noise" from disrupting the signal, but that's really not something that happens much. 

    Your Roku of course requires an HDMI connection, unless you have an older player with analog outputs. Since every Roku player is capable of higher resolution video than any DVD player, HDMI certainly provides the highest quality video signal compared to the old analog connection. Also be aware there are some DVD players that offer "upscaling" using an HDMI cable. However, while it might look a bit better than the analog video, it's being upscaled and the higher quality is artificial. With a Blu Ray disc, you are starting with a higher quality signal and it's not artificially being enhanced. 

    One additional comment about HDMI audio. Since almost every DVD is encoded with Dolby Digital audio, using an HDMI connection does keep that digital audio intact all the way to the TV. It's possible to have slightly better sounding audio if you keep that within the digital realm all the way to the audio amps in the TV. If you're using an AVR, then you can absolutely get better audio with an HDMI connection, even from a DVD.

    • mlissbuck's avatar
      mlissbuck
      Reel Rookie

      Dan,

      Thank you for the reply. I may have failed to elaborate on an important item. My Roku is a Smart TV—not the steaming player. I didn't know those existed until now 🙂 Anyhow, my Roku Smart TV is new out of the box and right now it has its power cable, HDMI cable plugged into DVD player and it’s hardwired to the nearby router at the moment “for improved signal.” I plan to get it mounted. Since this tv has built in audio and visual, if I simply leave it hardwired or change it to wifi connection, it’s audio and visual be at its peak? You mentioned how the HDMI kept audio and visual in the “digital realm,” but I assume this is for Roku steaming players—not the smart tv. If I’m understanding this correctly, Roku smart TV will produce amazing audio and visual whether connected via wifi or hardwire and the HDMI to DVD player, in this case, is solely for communication between the 2 devices.

       

       

      • mlissbuck's avatar
        mlissbuck
        Reel Rookie

        When reading about Roku, I must have reviewed content on the Roku player vs actual Roku Smart TV, which started my thinking about how to wire it for peak performance. 

  • I’m not sure I understand the question.  Blu Ray Players, Cable Boxes, Games, Streaming devices, etc. all connect to TVs via cables - usually HDMI.  The other option for some of those is component video cables, but component AV takes 5 cables instead of 1, so I don’t see how that would help you.

    When you wall mount, you certainly should think about cables and connectors, both now, and when adding devices in the future.