Roku TV ECP commands & power state

ECP commands were easy enough to guess.

Any comments from Roku on whether there's any way to keep the wireless adaptor live? It would make the TV infinitely more useful for me.

"WillEV" wrote:

...
Any comments from Roku on whether there's any way to keep the wireless adaptor live?
...

You might try the Setting options under System / Power / Auto power off and disable it (turn off the checkboxes).

"RokuKC" wrote:

"WillEV" wrote:

...
Any comments from Roku on whether there's any way to keep the wireless adaptor live?
...

You might try the Setting options under System / Power / Auto power off and disable it (turn off the checkboxes).

That's not what I'm looking for; that just stops the TV from turning off when it is on for X minutes/hours.

What I'm looking for is a way to stop the TV from going into deep sleep mode where the WiFi gets turned off 12 minutes or so after the TV gets powered off. I'd be more than happy for this not to be the default behavior, but it would be great if there could be another option in that menu "keep WiFi alive" so that IP control systems (including the Roku app) could power on the TV.

"WillEV" wrote:

...
What I'm looking for is a way to stop the TV from going into deep sleep mode where the WiFi gets turned off 12 minutes or so after the TV gets powered off. I'd be more than happy for this not to be the default behavior, but it would be great if there could be another option in that menu "keep WiFi alive" so that IP control systems (including the Roku app) could power on the TV.

Sorry, that is not an available option to my knowledge. When the Roku TV is off it is by design not running networking and IP control systems.

"RokuKC" wrote:

"WillEV" wrote:

...
What I'm looking for is a way to stop the TV from going into deep sleep mode where the WiFi gets turned off 12 minutes or so after the TV gets powered off. I'd be more than happy for this not to be the default behavior, but it would be great if there could be another option in that menu "keep WiFi alive" so that IP control systems (including the Roku app) could power on the TV.

Sorry, that is not an available option to my knowledge. When the Roku TV is off it is by design not running networking and IP control systems.

Is there any way to request that this is added?

A feature like this could have serious consequences, by increasing the average power usage of the TV. For example, it might cause it to fail Energy Star certification, which would be a non-starter. Even if it didn't, I think the decision makers would want to hear a pretty compelling use case to justify doing something like this.

--Mark

"RokuMarkn" wrote:
A feature like this could have serious consequences, by increasing the average power usage of the TV. For example, it might cause it to fail Energy Star certification, which would be a non-starter. Even if it didn't, I think the decision makers would want to hear a pretty compelling use case to justify doing something like this.

--Mark

I'd be more than happy for the default behavior for the TV have this be off, and make it a user selectable option. It basically renders the "roku-ness" of the TV all but useless in a control system environment, as there's no discrete IR codes for each input. If it was always live on the network, I'd accept a power increase in response to making the TV always able to be controlled. Without being able to turn it on over IP, the IP control doesn't get me anything.

"RokuMarkn" wrote:
A feature like this could have serious consequences, by increasing the average power usage of the TV. For example, it might cause it to fail Energy Star certification, which would be a non-starter. Even if it didn't, I think the decision makers would want to hear a pretty compelling use case to justify doing something like this.

The use case is: being able to turn RokuTV "on" over IP, the way it can be turned off already. A forward step in the "connected home" trend.

When they discover the power button in teh "Roku" remote app can be used to turn off the TV but not to power it up, the typical user reaction is:
[spoiler=WAT:5wvoaokg][/spoiler:5wvoaokg] - i.e. is counter- "principle of least astonishment".

A "proper" implementation may require some variety of Wake-on-LAN, be it wireless or wired-only. But how much energy would a RokuTV consume with screen off and working LAN, i wonder? (Not being a hardware guy,) it's my belief TV sets stay in sleep mode when turned off anyway, because of listening to the IR remote sensor. Maybe LAN adaptor does not consume much - or does it? (It can be an opt-in setting, as WillEV proposed).

"EnTerr" wrote:
But how much energy would a RokuTV consume with screen off and working LAN, i wonder?

I tried measuring and what i see is:

• 49 W working


• 13 W in light-sleep mode (~10 mins after remote power-off)


• 0 W thereafter

"EnTerr" wrote:

"EnTerr" wrote:
But how much energy would a RokuTV consume with screen off and working LAN, i wonder?

I tried measuring and what i see is:

• 49 W working


• 13 W in light-sleep mode (~10 mins after remote power-off)


• 0 W thereafter

Could 100% live with 13W consumption. I know for sure that's way too high for energy star certification, but if I could "disable" energy star mode to get always on IP control, I would be the happiest man in these pants.