Forum Discussion

bkgoodman's avatar
bkgoodman
Visitor
15 years ago

HLS Playback of more than 5 Fragments fails

A am in the process of developing a "channel" - and am creating some test content to test my streaming/encoding workflow, and am running into some issues. Due to the nature of what I am seeing, it doesn't seem like it is a problem in the encoding as so much as a problem with Roku...
I am following all Roku's guidelines on the encoding format, and am having minimal success as follows:

I create a video, and fragment it as required. (10 Second fragments, 380x360, 800k/bps, 23.98fps, etc. etc.)

When I go to play the video, the "Recieving" bar would start to fill up, then stop - without ever playing the video. As I susspected there might be a problem later in the video, I edited my m3u8 file to trim down the video (remove fragments from the end). When I got it down to about 5 fragments, the video played just fine.

So I figured there must be some problem with the 6th fragment, etc. I tried a lot with re-encoding, etc, never resolved the issue. Then I tried the following:

If I list the *same* fragment around 5 times - the video will play back properly. However, If I play the *same* fragment back more than 5 times, the playback gets stuck on "Recieving".

In experimenting further - I find that I can specify any 5 fragments and the playback will work. If I specify more than 5, playback will never properly start.

Any idea what the issue could be??

Brad Goodman
SeaChange International

12 Replies

  • Any update on this?

    I incidentally was able to obtain some output from a (very expensive) RGB encoder, which seemed to work properly.

    Any help on getting the FFMPEG generated content working would get this project back on track. Right now, Boxee seems to be my only answer...

    Thanks,

    -BKG
  • Any help on this?

    I'm finding the box unusable.

    Any way to debug what's going on?!?